Tip: press / anywhere to search. Or open a random note →

Handwritten notebook page explaining decision fatigue: the ego depletion idea, the 2016 and 2021 re-tests (23 labs, 2,141 people; 36 labs, 3,531 people), the hungry judges parole study and its critics, and two myths
Tap the note to see it full size

Productivity One-page note

Decision Fatigue: Myth vs Facts

"Every decision drains your willpower." Big pre-registered re-tests found little or no evidence. Here's the real story. Save this page.

Good to know

General info. The debate isn't fully closed.

What's on the page

The note as text, so you can read it, copy it or use a screen reader.

The idea

  • Willpower is like fuel in a tank
  • Each choice or effort uses some up
  • Psychologists called it "ego depletion"

Then it was re-tested

  • 2016: 23 labs, 2,141 people
  • Effect close to zero
  • 2021: 36 labs, 3,531 people
  • Preregistered tests found no evidence

The "hungry judges" study

  • 2011: Israeli parole decisions
  • Approvals fell from ~65% to nearly zero each session
  • Jumped back after breaks

But critics found

  • Favourable cases take longer to hear
  • Quicker cases (often refusals) may come last
  • Simulations: effect likely overestimated

Myths

  • "Science proves willpower runs out"
  • "Hunger proven to make judges harsher"

Sources

  1. Massey University: Hagger et al. (2016)
  2. University of Minnesota: Vohs et al. (2021)
  3. Tel Aviv University: Danziger et al. (2011)
  4. Hebrew University: Weinshall-Margel & Shapard (2011)
  5. PMC: Weinshall-Margel & Shapard (2011) letter
  6. Judgment and Decision Making: Glöckner (2016)
  7. Mind Hacks: "Rational judges, not extraneous factors in decisions" (2016)

How we checked this

Every fact on this note comes from the 7 sources listed here, checked against official or peer-reviewed sources where possible. AI tools help with drafting; a person checks every fact against the sources. How we research

Spotted a mistake? Tell us and we'll fix it and log it on the corrections page.

More from Productivity

All Productivity notes →