Tip: press / anywhere to search. Or open a random note →

Handwritten notebook page explaining why we overthink (rumination) and things that can help
The one-page note: “Why We Overthink (and How to Stop)”

Psychology Full guide See the one-page note →

Overthinking: why we do it and how to stop going round in circles

Why we overthink: what psychologists call rumination, why it makes problems harder, how it differs from problem-solving, and what can help.

Good to know

General info, not medical advice. UK and Ireland: Samaritans 116 123, free, any time.

On this page
  1. What is overthinking?
  2. Is overthinking bad for you?
  3. How is overthinking different from problem-solving?
  4. Things that can help with overthinking
  5. When to get help
  6. Common overthinking mistakes
  7. Related reading
  8. Sources

Overthinking is going over the same worry again and again without moving towards a solution, and psychologists call it "rumination". It feels like you are working on a problem, but research suggests it makes negative thinking worse and problems harder to solve. This article explains why overthinking matters, how it differs from real problem-solving, and some simple things that can help.

What is overthinking?

Overthinking is what psychologists call rumination: a repetitive, passive focus on distress. You go over the same worry again and again, without moving towards a solution.

The idea comes from the psychologist Nolen-Hoeksema. Her response styles theory (1991) described two ways people react to low mood: by ruminating on it, or by distracting themselves. Her 2008 review with Wisco and Lyubomirsky, "Rethinking Rumination", is a key paper on the topic.

Rumination vs worry

Both rumination and worry are forms of repetitive negative thinking. The difference is direction. Rumination looks back at the past ("Why did that happen?"). Worry looks ahead to the future ("What if it goes wrong?").

Is overthinking bad for you?

Overthinking isn't harmless thinking time. Research links it to real problems.

The "Rethinking Rumination" review says rumination "exacerbates depression, enhances negative thinking, impairs problem solving". That means it can make low mood worse, make negative thoughts stronger and make it harder to fix things.

The same review links rumination to depression and anxiety, and also to binge eating, drinking and self-harm.

How is overthinking different from problem-solving?

What separates them is whether your thinking leads to an action. Problem-solving moves you forward. Overthinking keeps you circling.

How is overthinking different from problem-solving?
Overthinking Problem-solving
"Why does this always happen to me?" "What's one thing I can do next?"
Passive: replays the problem Active: looks for a next step
Leaves you feeling stuck Leaves you with something to try

The two example sentences are our own illustrations. They show the difference Nolen-Hoeksema drew between passive, ruminative thinking and action-focused thinking.

A quick test: after a while spent thinking about something, do you have a next step? If not, you may be overthinking rather than solving.

Things that can help with overthinking

You can't always stop a thought from arriving, but you can change what you do next. These ideas come from psychology research summaries, the NHS and Samaritans.

Set a short daily "worry time"

Give your worries a fixed slot. Nolen-Hoeksema suggested setting a time for this, for example 30 minutes. The NHS Every Mind Matters guidance on anxiety gives similar advice: if worry takes over your day, set a fixed time each day to go through your worries.

Switch to something absorbing

Activities that fully hold your attention can shift your focus away from the loop. Pick something that needs your full attention, rather than something you can do while still replaying the worry.

Slow your breathing

Samaritans' "Finding your way" guide suggests slow breathing to help calm stress and anxiety. The NHS also says breathing exercises and relaxation can help calm anxiety.

The ancient Stoics drew a similar line between what is and isn't up to us. Our one-page guide to Stoicism and what's up to you explains the idea.

Talk to someone you trust

Samaritans recommends talking to someone you trust.

Self-help based on CBT

The NHS says self-help based on cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT) can help with worries and unhelpful thoughts. Every Mind Matters links to free CBT self-help techniques.

When to get help

If overthinking won't stop, or it affects your sleep and daily life, talk to your GP or doctor. A GP is a family doctor in the UK.

🇬🇧 UK: the NHS says to contact NHS 111 or talk to a GP if anxiety affects your daily life. 🇬🇧 England only: you can refer yourself for free NHS talking therapies without seeing a GP.

Need to talk right now?

🇬🇧 UK and Republic of Ireland: Samaritans, 116 123. It's free from any phone and open any time, 24 hours a day, 365 days a year.

Outside the UK and Ireland? Search for your country's crisis line.

This page is general information. It isn't a treatment for anxiety or depression.

Common overthinking mistakes

  • Thinking more will fix it. Rumination makes problem-solving harder, not easier.
  • Treating every "why" as progress. If thinking doesn't lead to a next step, it's probably a loop.
  • Waiting too long to talk to someone. If it's affecting sleep or daily life, speak to your GP or doctor.

Our guide to why we procrastinate looks at another way our thinking can keep us stuck.

Sources

How we checked this

Every fact in this article comes from the 7 sources listed above, checked against official or peer-reviewed sources where possible. AI tools help with drafting; a person checks every fact against the sources. How we research

Published and checked
Next check
Helpline details yearly

General info, not medical advice. UK and Ireland: Samaritans 116 123, free, any time.

Spotted a mistake? Tell us and we'll fix it and log it on the corrections page.

More from Psychology

All Psychology notes →

On this page

  1. What is overthinking?
  2. Is overthinking bad for you?
  3. How is overthinking different from problem-solving?
  4. Things that can help with overthinking
  5. When to get help
  6. Common overthinking mistakes
  7. Related reading
  8. Sources